What is the best eye liner that wont smudge and run into the lines under your eyes?

My eye liner and always comes off and runs into the lines under my eyesWhat is the best eye liner that wont smudge and run into the lines under your eyes?
omg, i had the same problem. i just got loreal infallible yesterday, i fell asleep with that on, and it says 16 hour wear, its been almost 24 HOURS and its still there!! its AMAZING.





also, i've heard revlon colorstay is pretty much the same too :).What is the best eye liner that wont smudge and run into the lines under your eyes?
this is totally the best eyeliner EVER!


i love it soooo much its waterproof also, i used to have the same exact problem!





heres a link :]


http://www.revlon.com/ProductCatalog/ProductDetails.aspx?ProductID=47
I use Bonne Bell it's great.





You can also use a bit of eyeshadow primer to keep it on.